Return home

Open EVERYDAY 11am-11pm
Thurs, Fri, Sat until 2am
WE DELIVER!

 

 

Open EVERYDAY 11am-11pm
Thurs, Fri, Sat until 2am
WE DELIVER!

1965 Seneca St. Buffalo, NY

MENU
 

WEEKDAY SPECIALS

MONDAY

ANY LARGE SPECIALTY PIZZA PLUS 20 SPECIALTY BONELESS WINGS
$24.99

ANY LARGE SPECIALTY PIZZA
$11.99

BUY 2 SUBS & GET THE 3RD FOR
$.99

TUESDAY

LARGE PIZZA CHEESE & 1 TOPPING
$10.99

WEDNESDAY

BUY 2 SUBS & GET THE 3RD FOR
$.99

2 LARGE PIZZA CHEESE & 1 TOPPING
$24.99

THURSDAY

X-LARGE PIZZA CHEESE & 1 TOPPING
$13.99

 

Wise Guys Menu

!!DISCLAIMERS!!  Wiseguys makes every effort to ensure that the prices and items listed on our menus are up to date and correct. However, the prices and items listed on our web site menu are NOT guaranteed, and are subject to change without notice.

Download menu

EVERYDAY SPECIALS

SMALL CHEESE & 1 TOPPING PIZZA & 10 WINGS OR 15 BONELESS WINGS
$16.99
LARGE CHEESE & 1 TOPPING PIZZA & 25 BONELESS WINGS
$26.99
LARGE CHEESE & 1 TOPPING PIZZA & 20 WINGS OR 9  CHICKEN FINGERS
$26.99
18″ X-LARGE CHEESE & 1 TOPPING PIZZA & 30 WINGS OR 35 BONELESS WINGS OR 15 CHICKEN FINGERS
$32.99
LARGE CHEESE & 1 TOPPING PIZZA & 50 WINGS OR 55 BONELESS WINGS OR 20 CHICKEN FINGERS
$39.99
SHEET CHEESE & 1 TOPPING PIZZA & 50 WINGS OR 55 BONELESS WINGS OR 20 CHICKEN FINGERS
$49.99

ADDITIONAL CHARGES APPLY FOR SPECIALTY SAUCES

LUNCH SPECIALS

ANY MINI COLD SUB & CHEF SALAD OR FRIES $6.99
PERSONAL ANTIPASTO & GARLIC BREAD $6.99
2 LARGE BEEF TACOS & 20 oz. POP $7.99
2 SLICES & 20oz OF POP $5.99
ANY COLD MINI SUB & 20 oz. POP $5.99
15 BONELESS WINGS & FRIES $8.99
2 SLICES & 5 WINGS $7.99
3 CHICKEN FINGERS & FRIES $7.99

BURGERS & SANDWICHES

On a Costanzo’s roll, includes fries, cole slaw & pickles. Onions upon request.

BACON CHEESEBURGER: One half pound Angus burger, crispy bacon smothered in american cheese, lettuce and tomato. $11.99
CHEESEBURGER: Half pound Angus burger, american cheese, lettuce and tomato. $10.99
BURNING JALAPENO AND ONION RING BURGER: Topped with fried jalapeno crispy onion rings, Pepper-Jack, lettuce, tomatoes and chipotle may on a Costanzo’s roll. It’s love at first bite. $11.99
BUFFALO CHICKEN SANDWICH: Chicken breast shaken in franks hot sauce with mozzarella cheese smothered in our homemade bluecheese. $11.99
PULLED PORK SANDWICH: Pulled pork cooked to perfection in a Jack Daniels BBQ sauce. $11.99

SALADS

DRESSING: Homemade Buttermilk Ranch, Italian, French, Homemade Bleu Cheese, Thousand Island, Raspberry Vinagrette

Chicken Souvlaki Salad $9.49
Antipasto $9.49
Julienne Salad $9.49
Steak $9.49
Chicken Finger $9.49
Grilled Chicken $9.49
Tuna $9.49
 Chef Salad $7.49
Taco Salad: Seasoned beef, fresh lettuce, tomato, salsa, sour cream, mozzarella, cheddar, and black olives. $9.49

TACOS, NACHOS AND QUESADILLAS

Served with Hot, Medium, Mild, Atomic hot, or Carolina Reaper

Served on a 12″ soft shell with lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.

ADD SOUR CREAM $.50 – ADD NACHO CHEESE $.75
ADD GREEN OR BLACK OLIVES, HOT, SWEET, CHERRY OR JALAPENO PEPPERS FOR $.75

Beef & Cheese $4.50
Steak or Chicken
$5.99
Chicken Finger Taco $5.99
Super Burrito – 1lb. seasoned beef $6.99
Dorito Supreme – Dorito chips, nacho cheese, ground beef, sour cream and salsa.
 – Extra nacho cheese, salsa or sour cream add $1.00 per item
$6.99
Quesadilla – NEW LARGER SIZE Steak, Chicken or Beef. $8.99
Fresh lettuce and tomato optional.

JUMBO & BONELESS CHICKEN WINGS

Includes Bleu Cheese, & Carrots.
Served with Frank’s Hot, Medium, Mild, or Open Pit BBQ
EXTRA BLEU CHEESE OR CARROTS $1.00**BONELESS WINGS ARE SERVED WITH FRIES**

 JUMBO REGULAR SPECIALTY
SINGLE (10) $10.99 $11.99
DOUBLE (20) $17.99 $19.99
TRIPLE (30) $23.99 $26.99
BUCKET (50) $33.99 $36.99
BONELESS & FRIES
SINGLE (15) $10.99 $11.99
DOUBLE (25) $17.99 $19.99
TRIPLE (35) $23.99 $26.99
BUCKET (55) $33.99 $36.99

IT’S A WING THING

SPECIALTY FLAVORED SAUCES FOR YOUR WINGS AND FINGERS

specialtySauces

Sweet Smokey BBQ Sriracha
Sweet Spicy BBQ Mango Habanero
Applewood Smoked Bacon BBQ Honey Sriracha
Dr. Pepper BBQ Sauce Honey Mustard
Honey Bourbon BBQ Chipotle Honey Mustard
Honey BBQ Honey Sesame
Char BBQ Spicy Honey Hot Sauce
Chipotle BBQ Honey Garlic
Kickin Bourbon Garlic Parmesan
Maple Bourbon Hot Garlic Parmesan
Kansas City Classic BBQ Creamy Ranch Parmesan
Hot & Spicy BBQ Zesty Orange Sauce
Roasted Garlic BBQ Asian Sweet Ginger
Loganberry BBQ General Tso
Dinosaur BBQ Sweet Chili
St. Louis Original BBQ Coconut Thai Chili
Cajun BBQ Sweet & Sour
Cajun Kickin Korean
Atomic Hot Jamaican Jerk 
Lemon Pepper  Chiavetta’s

Carolina Reaper

 WAIVER: I understand that Carolina Reaper is EXTREMELY spicy. Wise Guy’s cannot and will not be held responsible for any discomforts or unpleasant ‘experiences’ that could follow. Wise Guy’s is also not responsible for all other wings tasting bland and lifeless after consuming these bad boys!

CHICKEN FINGERS AND FRIES

SPECIALTY FLAVORED SAUCES FOR YOUR WINGS AND FINGERS

(5) $9.99 (10) 15.99 (22) $28.99

INCLUDES FRIES, CARROTS & BLEU CHEESE

ADDITIONAL CHARGES APPLY FOR SPECIALTY SAUCES

HOAGIES

All hoagies include fried onions fresh tomatoes, crisp lettuce, melted cheese and our homemade blend of hoagie oil.

8″ MINI
12″ WHOLE
Steak Hoagie $7.50 $8.99
Chicken Hoagie $7.50 $8.99
Turkey Hoagie $7.50 $8.99
Sausage Hoagie $7.50 $8.99
Cheeseburger Hoagie $7.50 $8.99
Steak & Chicken Hoagie $7.99 $10.99
Steak & Sausage Hoagie $7.99 $10.99
Steak & Spinach Hoagie $7.99 $10.99
Hoagie Supreme: includes peppers, mushrooms, spinach optional $7.99 $10.99
Stinger Hoagie: chopped steak & delicious chicken fingers sauced to your liking $7.99 $10.99
Steak & Bacon Hoagie $7.99 $10.99

ADD YOUR CHOICE OF:Delicious sautéed mushrooms, hot or sweet peppers, jalapeños, cherry peppers, spinach,extra cheese, or double meat.ADDITIONAL CHARGES MY APPLY.

 

SUBS

All subs start off with a fresh Costanzo’s roll:
White, Rustic, or garlic bread available.
Then a choice of cheese: Mozzarella, Provolone, Swiss American.
All subs come with Fresh Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Onions unless otherwise specified.

8″ MINI
12″ WHOLE
Assorted – ham, salami, and capicola
$5.99 $8.99
Bacon Cheese Burger
$5.99 $8.99
BBQ Pulled Pork
$5.99 $8.99
BCB & Onion Ring
$5.99 $9.25
BLT $4.99 $7.99
Bologna $4.50 $7.99
Capicola – Margherita capicola
$5.50 $7.99
Cheese – baked on request
$4.99 $7.99
Cheeseburger $4.99 $7.99
Chicken Breast – delicious white meat chicken $5.99 $8.75
Chicken Breast and Bacon
$6.25 $9.25
Chicken Finger $5.99 $7.99
Chicken Finger Club $6.50 $9.25
Chicken Parm $5.99 $7.99
Chicken Souvlaki $5.99 $8.50
Fish Sub – 10 oz. beer battered haddock N/A $8.99
Fried Bologna & Onions $4.99 $7.99
Fried Capicola $5.50 $7.99
Ham – Sahlen’s smoked ham $5.50 $7.99
Ham & Turkey – Sahlen’s ham & premium turkey $5.99 $8.99
Hitman – sausage, capicola, ham & salami (hot sauce optional) $6.50 $9.25
Italian Sausage $4.99 $7.50
Meatball $4.99 $7.99
Pizza – mozzarella & pepperoni $4.99 $7.99
Pizza Burger $5.50 $8.50
Roast Beef – USDA Top Round Roast Beef $4.99 $7.99
Royal Sausage & Capicola $4.99 $8.50
Salami – Margherita Salami $4.99 $7.99
Sausage Meatball $4.99 $8.25
Steak Sub $5.99 $8.99
Tuna $4.99 $7.99
Turkey – Gourmet premium turkey $5.50 $7.50
Turkey Club $5.99 $8.50
White Pizza $4.99 $6.99

 

PIZZA

Served with our freshly homemade fresh pizza dough.
Now serving a Traditional Pizza Sauce as well as our Original Sauce.
Additional charges for thin crust or double dough.

Slice of Pizza $2.50 Personal Pizza (9″) plus 1 topping $5.99
Available as any specialty personal $7.99
Cheese Plus 1 Topping Extra Topping
(13″) Small Cheese $9.99 $10.99 $1.25
(16″) Large Cheese $13.99 $14.99 $1.99
(18″) X-Large Cheese $16.99 $18.99 $2.75
SHEET CHEESE $24.99 $27.99 $4.50

EXTRA ITEMS:
Black Olives, Capicola, Green Olives, Onions, Fresh Tomatoes, Mushrooms, Taco Beef, Hot Peppers, Spinach, Sweet Peppers, Italian Sausage, Jalapeno Peppers, Cherry Peppers & Pepperoni
Bacon, Extra Cheese, Anchovies, Ham, Pineapple, Chicken,

ADDITIONAL CHARGES FOR: Steak, Chicken Fingers, Beef Pepporoni

SPECIALTY PIZZA

SM. $14.25 – LG. $17.99 – XLG. $20.99 – SHEET $29.99

10in Gluten Free $12.99

Steak Pizza: Homemade dough, smothered in our very own blend of hoagie oil, layered with five different cheeses, fresh onions, garlic baked mushrooms and freshly seasoned steak.
Taco Pizza: Old El Paso salsa base, seasoned ground beef, smothered with mozzarella, cheddar, and monterey jack cheeses, topped with black olives, and fresh tomatoes. Fresh lettuce upon request.
White Pizza: Our very own blend of olive oil, minced garlic, fried onions, fresh tomatoes and mozzarella. Topped off with oregano and parmesan.
Hawaiian: Homemade pizza dough with our delicious red sauce base, topped with Sahlen’s ham, fresh chunks of pineapple, and delectable maraschino cherries
Bacon Cheese Burger: Our house Thousand Island dressing base, Angus Burgers, covered in mozzarella, cheddar, and monterey jack cheeses, topped with bits of delicious bacon!! Fresh lettuce and tomato upon request.
Chicken Bacon Ranch. Our house Ranch dressing with chunks of seasoned chicken breast grilled to perfection. Topped with mozzarella, cheddar, monterey jack cheeses, and delicious bits of bacon!
Vegetarian: Choose five of our freshest veggies piled on our signature pizza dough with your choice of red sauce, olive oil, or Alfredo sauce.
Chicken Deluxe: Your choice of chicken breast, spinach, fresh tomato and your choice of red, white, or Alfredo sauce.
Chicken Finger: Homemade pizza dough covered in your choice of sauce, chunks of chicken fingers shaken to your liking, covered in mozzarella, cheddar, and monterey jack cheese.
Chicken Club Tender: Pieces of all white Chicken Breast, Mozzarella, Swiss & American Cheese with Sahlens Ham, Crispy Bacon and fresh slices of bacon or Tomato.
BBQ Pulled Pork: Signature pizza dough, smothered in Honey BBQ sauce, with delicious pulled pork, topped with mozzarella, and cheddar jack cheeses.
Buffalo Chicken Pizza: Delicious chunks of chicken breast shaken in your choice of wing sauce, with a sour cream base covered in mozzarella, and cheddar jack cheeses topped with bleu cheese crumbles, bits of celery, tomatoes, and chive onions.
Breakfast Pizza: Our thin crust signature pizza dough covered with eggs, Sahlen’s Ham, bacon, and sausage on top of mozzarella, and cheddar jack cheeses. Peppers and onions upon request.
Chicken FajitaOur homemade salsa covered with seasoned chicken breast, purple onions, sweet peppers, tomatoes, mozzarella, cheddar, and monterey jack cheeses and topped with sour cream. Hot, medium or mild sauce added upon request.
Greek: Our house Greek dressing as a base piled high with fresh onions, sweet peppers, tomatoes, Greek olives, with feta and mozzarella cheese.
Chicken Souvlaki: Our house Greek dressing as a base piled high with grilled chicken breast, fresh onions, tomatoes, Black olives, with feta and mozzarella cheese.
Steak Souvlaki: Our house Greek dressing as a base piled high with sirloin steak, fresh onions, tomatoes, Black olives, with feta and mozzarella cheese.
BBQ Chicken Pizza: Our grilled chicken breast shaken in Honey BBQ sauce with mozzarella and cheddar jack cheeses, with bits of bacon all piled high on our signature pizza dough.
Southwest Chicken Pizza: Honey BBQ chicken, with fresh tomatoes, onions, sweet peppers, and black olives with mozzarella and cheddar jack cheeses.

 

PREMIUM SPECIALTY PIZZA

SM. $16.25 – LG. $20.99 – XLG. $22.99 – SHEET $33.99

Stinger Pizza: Our Signature Pizza Dough covered with your choice of Chicken Wing Sauce, a blend of Bleu Cheese, and White American Cheese, Topped with Sirloin Steak, your choice of Chicken Fingers, and Mozzarella and Cheddar Cheese.
Lasagna Pizza: Our dough with our homemade Pizza Sauce with Ricotta cheese, meatballs and sausage topped with Romano and Mozzarella cheese on a garlic crust.
Stuffed Hot Pepper Pizza: Olive Oil, light Onions, Ricotta and Cream Cheese, Roasted hot Peppers, topped with Italian Sausage on a garlic crust
Supreme: Pepperoni, sausage, fresh chopped onions, garlic baked mushrooms, and your choice of hot, sweet, red hot cherry or jalapeno peppers.
Meat Lovers: Pepperoni, bacon, ham, sausage, and chunks of chicken breast.
Deluxe White Pizza: Our house olive oil dressing base with freshly minced garlic and fried onions covered with mozzarella cheese, freshly diced tomatoes with your choice of peppers, and one meat of your choice.
BCB and Onion Ring BBQ: Angus Burgers covered in mozzarella, cheddar and Monterey jack cheeses, with delicious bits or bacon and onion rings on a honey bbq base. Lettuce, Tomatoes, upon request.
Steak Breakfast Pizza: Our thin crust signature pizza dough covered with eggs, and sirloin steak on top of mozzarella, and cheddar jack cheeses. Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, upon request.
Chicken & Steak: Our signature hoagie oil base with chopped sirloin steak and seasoned chicken breast piled high and topped with four different cheeses! Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms upon request.

 

DINNERS

 

4 Piece Fried Chicken
Includes fries, coleslaw, & garlic toast
$11.99
Daily Fish Fry 10 oz. Beer Battered Haddock
Includes fries, coleslaw, macaroni & potato salad & garlic toast.
$12.50

DELICIOUS SIDES

Small Large
Deep Fried Pickles (6) $5.99 (12) $8.99
Jalapeno Poppers OR Mozzarella Sticks (6) $5.99 (12) $8.99
Deep Fried Ravioli (6) $5.99 (12) $8.99
Pizza Logs (4) $5.99 (8) $8.99
Deep Fried Mushrooms OR Cauliflower $5.99 $9.99
Garlic Bread Sticks $5.99
Garlic Bread Sticks w/cheese $8.99
Oven Baked Garlic Bread w/cheese $5.99
French Fries $3.50
Deluxe Fries: Bacon OR taco meat with cheddar, mozzarella OR nacho cheese. Sour cream extra. $6.99
Shaken Fries: Choice of ranch OR bleu cheese shaken in medium sauce, smothered in mozzarella and cheddar. $6.99
Smothered Potato Wedges: Covered with melted mozzarella, cheddar, bacon & sour cream on the side. $6.99
Steak Cut Onion Rings $4.99
Sample Platter: 4 Pizza logs, 6 mozzarella sticks, 2 chicken fingers, french fries, and 8 deep fried ravoli. $15.99
20 stuffed steak and chicken nacho chips $5.99
Steak Hoagie Fries $7.99

DESSERTS

Dessert Calzone: Apple, Cherry or Strawberry filling $7.99
Fried Dough: Smothered in butter, powdered sugar & cinnamon
$4.50
Add Apple, Cherry or Strawberry topping
$1.50
Cannoli’s: (3) delicious ricotta chocolate chips dusted with powdered sugar
$5.50