Join the MafiaReceive updates on special events, new menu items, menu reviews, and more!

Burgers and Sandwiches

On a Costanzo' s roll, includes fries, cole slaw & pickles. Onions upon request.

Subs

All subs start off with a fresh Costanzo's roll:
White, Rustic, or garlic bread available.
Then a choice of cheese: Mozzarella, Provolone, Swiss American.
All subs come with Fresh Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Onions unless otherwise specified.

Assorted

ham, salami, and capicola

8″ Mini $712″ Whole $9

2 reviews

BLT

8″ Mini $712″ Whole $9

22 pops

Cheese

baked on request

8″ Mini $612″ Whole $8

Chicken Breast

delicious white meat chicken

8″ Mini $912″ Whole $11

Chicken Finger

8″ Mini $712″ Whole $10.50

617 pops2 reviews

Chicken Parm

8″ Mini $712″ Whole $10

1 review

Ham

Sahlen's smoked ham

8″ Mini $6.5012″ Whole $9

22 pops

Hitman

sausage, capicola, ham & salami (hot sauce optional)

8″ Mini $912″ Whole $13

44 pops

Meatball

8″ Mini $712″ Whole $10

Royal Sausage & Capicola

8″ Mini $912″ Whole $13

11 pop

Sausage Meatball

8″ Mini $812″ Whole $12

22 pops2 reviews

Tuna

8″ Mini $712″ Whole $9

112 pops

Turkey Club

8″ Mini $7.5012″ Whole $10

1 review

11 pop1 review

Bacon Cheese Burger

718 pops5 reviews

Capicola

Margherita capicola

8″ Mini $712″ Whole $9

Cheeseburger

8″ Mini $812″ Whole $10

11 pop1 review

Chicken Breast and Bacon

8″ Mini $9.5012″ Whole $12

Chicken Finger Club

8″ Mini $7.5012″ Whole $12

11 pop

Chicken Souvlaki

8″ Mini $712″ Whole $10

213 pops

Ham & Turkey

Sahlen's ham & premium turkey

12″ Whole $108″ Mini $7

1 review

11 pop1 review

Italian Sausage

8″ Mini $7.5012″ Whole $11

22 pops

Pizza

mozzarella & pepperoni

8″ Mini $712″ Whole $9

2 reviews

11 pop2 reviews

Salami

Margherita Salami

8″ Mini $612″ Whole $9

22 pops

Steak Sub

8″ Mini $812″ Whole $10

123 pops1 review

Turkey

Gourmet premium turkey

8″ Mini $612″ Whole $9

112 pops1 review

Baked Sicilian Sub

$13

Sausage, Bacon, Mozzarella and Parmesan. All baked on a Garlic Toast Roll with fried onions and your choice of pepper.

12" WHOLE $138" MINI $9

112 pops

Hoagies

All hoagies include fried onions, fresh tomatoes, crisp lettuce, melted cheese and our homemade blend of hoagie oil.

ADD YOUR CHOICE OF: Delicious sautéed mushrooms, hot or sweet peppers, jalapeños, cherry peppers, spinach, extra cheese, or double meat. ADDITIONAL CHARGES MY APPLY.

Steak Hoagie

8″ Mini $912″ Whole $12.50

3 reviews

527 pops3 reviews

Turkey Hoagie

8″ Mini $7.5012″ Whole $11

Steak & Chicken Hoagie

8″ Mini $9.5012″ Whole $13.50

11 pop

Steak & Spinach Hoagie

8″ Mini $9.5012″ Whole $13

1 review

213 pops1 review

Stinger Hoagie

chopped steak & delicious chicken fingers sauced to your liking

8″ Mini $1012″ Whole $14

1 review

3126 pops1 review

Chicken Hoagie

8″ Mini $8.5012″ Whole $13

22 pops1 review

Sausage Hoagie

8″ Mini $812″ Whole $11

11 pop

Steak & Sausage Hoagie

8″ Mini $9.5012″ Whole $13.50

Hoagie Supreme

Includes peppers, mushrooms, spinach optional

8″ Mini $9.5012″ Whole $13.50

22 pops2 reviews

Jay's Steak & Bacon Hoagie

8″ Mini $9.5012″ Whole $13.50

112 pops

Sandwiches and Subs

Burgers and Sandwiches

Bacon Cheese Burger

Kickin' Bourbon Burger

Burning Jalapeno And Onion Ring Burger

Subs

Assorted

BLT

Cheese

Chicken Breast

Chicken Finger

Chicken Parm

Ham

Hitman

Meatball

Royal Sausage & Capicola

Sausage Meatball

Tuna

Turkey Club

Bacon Cheese Burger

Capicola

Cheeseburger

Chicken Breast and Bacon

Chicken Finger Club

Chicken Souvlaki

Ham & Turkey

Italian Sausage

Pizza

Salami

Steak Sub

Turkey

Baked Sicilian Sub

Hoagies

Steak Hoagie

Turkey Hoagie

Steak & Chicken Hoagie

Steak & Spinach Hoagie

Stinger Hoagie

Chicken Hoagie

Sausage Hoagie

Steak & Sausage Hoagie

Hoagie Supreme

Jay's Steak & Bacon Hoagie