Skip to main content
Write a Review, Win $500! Help guests by leaving a review of your favorite dishes. Be entered in a drawing to win $500 on 2/1.
Wise Guys Pizza
  • Menu
  • Specials
  • Order Online
    Earn 1 #MobPoint for every $1 spent online
  • Catering
  • About
  • Coupons
  • Community
  • Contact
    Contact Employment Donations
  • Testimonials
    Read Testimonials Leave a Review
  • Feedback
  • Donations
pizza and wings

Sandwiches and Subs

Join the MafiaReceive updates on special events, new menu items, menu reviews, and more!

Sandwiches and Subs

Burgers and Sandwiches

On a Costanzo' s roll, includes fries, cole slaw & pickles. Onions upon request.

Bacon Cheese Burger

$15

One half pound Angus burger, crispy baconsmothered in american cheese, lettuce and tomato.

718 pops4 reviews
 

Kickin' Bourbon Burger

$15

Our signature bourbon BBQ sauce, crispy onion straws, cheddar cheese,lettuce, tomatoes, and Mayo

 

Burning Jalapeno And Onion Ring Burger

$15

Topped with fried jalapeno crispy onion rings, Pepper-Jack, lettuce, tomatoes and chipotle may on a Costanzo's roll. It's love at first bite.

11 pop
 

Subs

All subs start off with a fresh Costanzo's roll:
White, Rustic, or garlic bread available.
Then a choice of cheese: Mozzarella, Provolone, Swiss American.
All subs come with Fresh Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Onions unless otherwise specified.

Assorted

ham, salami, and capicola

8″ Mini $712″ Whole $9
2 reviews
 

BLT

8″ Mini $712″ Whole $9
22 pops
 

Cheese

baked on request

8″ Mini $612″ Whole $8
 

Chicken Breast

delicious white meat chicken

8″ Mini $912″ Whole $11
 

Chicken Finger

8″ Mini $712″ Whole $10.50
516 pops2 reviews
 

Chicken Parm

8″ Mini $712″ Whole $10
1 review
 

Ham

Sahlen's smoked ham

8″ Mini $6.5012″ Whole $9
22 pops
 

Hitman

sausage, capicola, ham & salami (hot sauce optional)

8″ Mini $912″ Whole $13
44 pops
 

Meatball

8″ Mini $712″ Whole $10
Meatball
 

Royal Sausage & Capicola

8″ Mini $912″ Whole $13
11 pop
 

Sausage Meatball

8″ Mini $812″ Whole $12
22 pops2 reviews
 

Tuna

8″ Mini $712″ Whole $9
112 pops
 

Turkey Club

8″ Mini $7.5012″ Whole $10
Turkey Club
1 review
11 pop1 review
 

Bacon Cheese Burger

718 pops4 reviews
 

Capicola

Margherita capicola

8″ Mini $712″ Whole $9
 

Cheeseburger

8″ Mini $812″ Whole $10
11 pop1 review
 

Chicken Breast and Bacon

8″ Mini $9.5012″ Whole $12
 

Chicken Finger Club

8″ Mini $7.5012″ Whole $12
11 pop
 

Chicken Souvlaki

8″ Mini $712″ Whole $10
213 pops
 

Ham & Turkey

Sahlen's ham & premium turkey

12″ Whole $108″ Mini $7
Ham & Turkey
1 review
1 review
 

Italian Sausage

8″ Mini $7.5012″ Whole $11
11 pop
 

Pizza

mozzarella & pepperoni

8″ Mini $712″ Whole $9
Pizza
2 reviews
11 pop2 reviews
 

Salami

Margherita Salami

8″ Mini $612″ Whole $9
Salami
 

Steak Sub

8″ Mini $812″ Whole $10
123 pops1 review
 

Turkey

Gourmet premium turkey

8″ Mini $612″ Whole $9
112 pops
 

Baked Sicilian Sub

$13

Sausage, Bacon, Mozzarella and Parmesan. All baked on a Garlic Toast Roll with fried onions and your choice of pepper.

12" WHOLE $138" MINI $9
Baked Sicilian Sub
112 pops
 

Hoagies

All hoagies include fried onions, fresh tomatoes, crisp lettuce, melted cheese and our homemade blend of hoagie oil.

ADD YOUR CHOICE OF: Delicious sautéed mushrooms, hot or sweet peppers, jalapeños, cherry peppers, spinach, extra cheese, or double meat. ADDITIONAL CHARGES MY APPLY.

Steak Hoagie

8″ Mini $912″ Whole $12.50
Steak Hoagie
3 reviews
527 pops3 reviews
 

Turkey Hoagie

8″ Mini $7.5012″ Whole $11
 

Steak & Chicken Hoagie

8″ Mini $9.5012″ Whole $13.50
11 pop
 

Steak & Spinach Hoagie

8″ Mini $9.5012″ Whole $13
Steak & Spinach Hoagie
1 review
213 pops1 review
 

Stinger Hoagie

chopped steak & delicious chicken fingers sauced to your liking

8″ Mini $1012″ Whole $14
Stinger Hoagie
1 review
2125 pops1 review
 

Chicken Hoagie

8″ Mini $8.5012″ Whole $13
22 pops1 review
 

Sausage Hoagie

8″ Mini $812″ Whole $11
11 pop
 

Steak & Sausage Hoagie

8″ Mini $9.5012″ Whole $13.50
 

Hoagie Supreme

Includes peppers, mushrooms, spinach optional

8″ Mini $9.5012″ Whole $13.50
22 pops2 reviews
 

Jay's Steak & Bacon Hoagie

8″ Mini $9.5012″ Whole $13.50
112 pops
 
Made with by Popmenu
Wise Guys Pizza
Website Accessibility Assistance
Opens in a new windowOpens an external siteOpens an external site in a new window