Add Your Review
Thanks for visiting Wise Guys Pizza. We'd love to have your feedback!
Our Latest Reviews
(16″) Large Cheese
Best pizza in South Buffalo hands down! Try the garlic Parmesan crust. Amazing :) Always delicious and never overpriced.
Chicken Finger
These guys have buffalo chicken wing pizza down to a science. I have had plenty of pizzas from different "popular" Buffalo pizzerias that have been disappointing, and Wise Guys always gets it right!The staff is caring and friendly,and the food has always been absolutely delicious. Don't get me started on wings and sauces, because the "other guys" can't hold a candle to what Wise Guys is cooking up.Next Level. As a Buffalo local,this is MY pizzeria.
18″ X-large Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza & 30 Wings Or 35 Boneless Wings Or 15 Chicken Fingers
We got the stuffed crust pizza special 2 weeks ago and it was enormous and delicious! 10/10 would order again!
(16″) Large Cheese
The pizza is out if this world! The crust cooked to perfection and the pepperoni is so delicious! I highly recommend this pizza! Bring back the deep fried garlic bread!!!!
Lasagna Pizza
The large lasagna pizza was SO GOOD! I ordered a large c&p pizza with it for the rest of the family because they weren't sure they'd like the lasagna one. But after each of them tried a bite of it, they couldn't help but have a couple slices each! We'll definitely be getting it again! The brownies are delicious as well!
18″ X-large Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza & 30 Wings Or 35 Boneless Wings Or 15 Chicken Fingers
Absolutely love there pizza, They use the best pepperoni, always ordering there xl pizza and 30 wings, it's a great deal, when it's pizza night I'm ordering from wise guys 9/10 times
Vegetarian
We order the vegetarian pizza for our whole office and it is a huge hit - best veggie pizza around!
18″ X-large Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza & 30 Wings Or 35 Boneless Wings Or 15 Chicken Fingers
I was a long time customer of another pizza place. But i wanted to try something new. Well im glad i did, i have had multiple items from here and im impressed with the quality and quanity. I was most impressed to find out how much they give back to the community and customer service is top of the list. Thank you for changing my mind i should of done it sooner.
2 Slices & 5 Boneless Wings
Best pizza place in town! Been my go to for years! 🍕😋
Garlic Bread Sticks w/cheese
Hi Wise Guys! I hope you share this review to the world because you are amazing. I just ordered a fish fry with garlic breadsticks and pretzels and it is gigantic! Not to mention delicious. Plus the preparation and delivery to my house was very quick! You made my day. Thank you!
(13″) Small Cheese
excellent. No wonder Sexy Slices gave them an A+. Beautifully thick dough, sweet sauce, and enormous amount of cheese with the char'd cup pepperoni. the $20 small cheese and pepperoni with 10 wings is a great deal!
(16″) Large Cheese
Wise Guys is by far the best pizza in the city of Buffalo!!! All the love they put into it with the pepperoni 🍕 and cheese. Mmmmm perfection.
(13″) Small Cheese
The food is amazing, the prices are decent and all tje employees are so kind and curteous...my favorite pizza joint of all time..
18″ X-large Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza & 30 Wings Or 35 Boneless Wings Or 15 Chicken Fingers
Pizza wings and subs are incredible. The variety of desserts are amazing and delicious. Cannot say enough how awesome the food is and what a great contributor to the community Wiseguys is.
18″ X-large Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza & 30 Wings Or 35 Boneless Wings Or 15 Chicken Fingers
We love Wiseguys! Best pizza, biggest and best wings, and the best blue cheese.
(16″) Large Cheese
They have the best pizza in Buffalo by far!!! I've previously ordered subs, wings, and tacos, and everything was delicious!! Also the staff is always so friendly. If you haven't ordered here you're missing out!
(16″) Large Cheese
Large steak pizza f*@$%^g awesome!
Slice of Pizza
Great
Sheet Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza & 50 Wings Or 55 Boneless Wings Or 20 Chicken Fingers
We ordered the sheet with chicken fingers! PERFECTION!!! Fingers great quality and great taste pizza was cooked to perfection! And the blue cheese yum 😋!
Assorted
The sub sausage was awesome and chicken parmesan was even better. Love eating at this place because of the food, service and environment is calm.
(16″) Large Cheese
The pizza at WiseGuys is ALWAYS on point! Seriously the ONLY place I will order pizza from! Always a definite hit with my kids!
Hoagie Supreme
this sub was awesome
(16″) Large Cheese
Wise guys pizza is the most delicious pizza in all of Buffalo. Classic south Buffalo pizza place. Always a very pleasant customer service experience as well and we love the ease of their website.
18″ X-large Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza & 30 Wings Or 35 Boneless Wings Or 15 Chicken Fingers
My family and I are born and raised Buffalo pizza junkies. We have to say that Wise Guys is BY FAR the best Pizza we have had. Very consistant, prices are fair. Your pizza crust, sauce and all your toppings are fantastic. Your wings are also very good too! Keep up the good work folks!!
(16″) Large Cheese
We had a thin crust pizza and a calzone ,They we're both amazing. been looking for a good place to get thin crust pizza and wise guys definitely delivered..
18″ X-large Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza & 30 Wings Or 35 Boneless Wings Or 15 Chicken Fingers
Best Pizza in Buffalo I lived in south buffalo for 7 years and this was the only place I ever got my pizza from my family loves it. Just recently moved to North Tonawanda and I still travel for the pizza and wings. Everything is always fresh and taste very good. The employees do a very good job !!
Doritos Supreme
this menu item was great. ordered it a few times for the kids they loved it!!
15 Boneless Wings & Fries
The loganberry bbq boneless wings are the best thing on the planet
Deep Fried Cheesecake (2)
There's nothing else like it, it's a must have with any order 👍🏿🙏
Dillon's Famous Fish Fry
Our fav pizza & best customer service! Hubbie a little skeptical to try a pizza place fish fry & was pleasantly surprised at taste/quality/portion. Even better than some of the "best fish fry" restaurants we have tried. Definitely recommend Wise Guys for any of their menu items!
Bacon Cheese Burger
Best Pizza, Subs and Wings in Buffalo! Friendly employees and its much appreciated. Thank you!
Stinger Hoagie
the stinger was delicious- it was overflowing with steak and chicken fingers that had great flavor.
Shaken Fries
This is my favorite sides I order every time! It is a large portion and so delicious! It is a true Buffalo dish!
Antipasto
Tons of meat and cheese. Definitely enough for a group of people.
Assorted
Had whole assorted and turkey subs. VERY generous on meats and ingredients. Also had piece of the chocolate cake...defintly treat yourself to a slice of this hidden treasure. Been coming to Wiseguys since they opened and will continue til the day I die....best in town
Dillon's Famous Fish Fry
Phenomenal. Always satisfied when I order wise guys
Calzone
Ive had calzones before but nothing really compares to the value of the ones wise guys makes! Great price and it was huge! Fed two kids and myself. Was delicious! Best calzone i ever ordered in my life!! Thank you!
(16″) Large Cheese
100% the best pizza in Buffalo! Their sauce is incredible- I tell everyone- "order from WiseGuys!"
2 Slices & 20oz Of Pop
I've had this I love the slices they're really large and the sauce taste really good. The service is really professional and polite. I just wish they would make them without pepperoni. Just plain cheese.
PAST DRAWING WINNERS
May 2020:
Coming Soon
April 2020:
Sommer, Little Calf Creamery
Thousand Oaks, CA
March 2020:
Theresa, Woody's Crab House
North East, MD
February 2020:
Maria, The Rustik Fork
Riverside, CA
January 2020:
Marsha, Stefano's Restaurant
Florence, SC
December 2019:
Alma, Karai Ramen Bistro
Jacksonville, FL
November 2019:
Courtney, Axe & Arrow
Seattle, WA
October 2019:
Andy, Backwoods Brewing Co.
Portland, OR
September 2019:
Amanda, Home Restaurant
Los Angeles, CA
August 2019:
Jennifer, Mark's City Grill
Columbus, GA
July 2019:
Rebecca, Frank Gourmet
Buffalo, NY
June 2019:
Donna, Dino's Sports Bar
Cape Cod, MA
May 2019:
Karen, This Little Pig
Amherst, NY
April 2019:
Alicia, Plant Based Pizzeria
Atlanta, GA