Add Your Review
Thanks for visiting Wise Guys Pizza. We'd love to have your feedback!
Our Latest Reviews
I love bacon cheese burger pizza very yummy food
It was delicious!!
Absolutely AMAZING......Best Fish Fry that I have had the pleasure of eating....Wise Guys has been still is and will Always be the Best in Our South Buffalo Area...
Your pizza is delicious and your customer service is excellent!!! Thank you!
The Tony Soprano is such a legendary pizza! The beer cheese base perfectly compliments all of the other toppings. When you're looking for something different in a pizza Wise guys always delivers!
It's a cliche to say "best pizza in buffalo" but this is it! Our family looooves your pizza! 😋
Wiseguys never disappoints! The pizza and wings are by far our favorite in South Buffalo. Can't go wrong with any of the food here.
(18″) X-Large Cheese
We moved to S. Buff about 6 yrs ago & were ordering from another place. When they raised their prices for 3rd time in 5 yrs we decided to try some place else. We are so glad we did! Wiseguy's has some of the best pizza & wings around! Seriously, delicious! Big wings, juicy on the inside, crispy on the outside. Pizza is also fantastic, every time. Specialty oils on the crust are a bonus - delicious! And the homemade bleu cheese is off-the-chart. Lastly, as a dog owner, I appreciate the calls/texts when you're order is on its way or the driver's there. I know, it seems silly, but that type of sincere touch makes a difference. We're sold on Wiseguys. Good job!
(16″) Large Cheese
Wise Guy's pizza is always our go to and #1 favorite pizza. Anytime we order from Wise Guys the food is excellent. The pizza is always on point! It doesn't matter if we pick it up or have it delivered, it's always fresh and hot. What really makes Wise Guys great is the quality ingredients that are used for all of the dishes. The staff is great also, I have never had a bad experience ordering or picking up any orders!
Awesome food even better service live this place lots
Best steak pizza around! You'll never be disappointed in anything you order from here. Great quality, portions and price.
They have the best honey bbq chicken wings ever even their pizza is the best highly recommend Wiseguys
The best Hawaiian Pizza in Buffalo & their Loganberry BBQ Sauce is my all time favorite. I want that sauce on EVERYTHING!
Ordered lg cheese and pepperoni pizza for the first time last month. I will say it was delicious! Perfect amount of sauce and cheese. Will be telling my friends to order and will be enjoying a great pizza soon!
AMAZING pizza!! new favorite spot... need to try the whole menu now:) wings were spectacular as well, definitely recommend Wise Guys!!
Wise Guys is my go to place for Pizza and Wings. I was raised in South Buffalo and as a kid always picked them for pizza night. Even now, after moving out of the neighborhood, I'll drive over to Seneca St. to pick up my order because I'd rather have Wise Guys than any other pizzeria.
I've been to 40 states, ordered subs & hoagies from all of them. Been doing business with Wise Guys for 25 years. Nothing competes with their steak hoagie. 5 starts straight up!
I ordered a steak/cheese specialty pizza and it was the best pizza I have ever had. The steak oil on the base of the pizza was very good there was ample shredded steak on it and plenty of cheese I am new to the area and this is my first time ordering from wise guy pizza, but I'm happy I found such a good pizzeria and cannot wait to try other menu items. I must also say the menu choices are extensive.
I ordered a fish fry, slice of cherry cheesecake and a steak and cheese sub on a hoagie roll with mozzarella, fried onions and mushrooms. My family loves wiseguys n are frequent customers of wiseguys. Occasionally we have issues with our orders. Tonight are food was not its best. Honestly the fish fry could have been better n did not taste like haddock at all. My sub was ok but steak was missing flavor. I am not sure if it was just a rough night or something else. Normally our food is amazing. My family's favorites are the pizza/wings, bacon cheeseburger dinner n the assorted sub. We really do love wiseguys restaurant. The employees n staff are always friendly. If there is ever an issue with anything, jay is always on it making sure to take care of his customers.
Whenever I do not feel like cooking, WISEGUYS ALWAYS SAVES THE DAY! They have the best pizza and wings in the City. There's always smiles when I order WISEGUYS!
Large Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza & 20 Wings Or 9 Chicken Fingers
Pizza is excellent and wings are even better.
18″ X-large Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza & 30 Wings Or 35 Boneless Wings Or 15 Chicken Fingers
I have to say with me living in buffalo for 35 years, this pizza is the best. I have had pizza from all over town and by far hands down this is the best. Many competitors but none come close.
(16″) Large Cheese
I LOVE WISE GUYS pizza and wings, I order here often. The lemon pepper wings are sooooo good, I have yet to try anything else there because I always want their pizza and wings combo. One of the best in Buffalo 💗🍕💗🍕
Wiseguys is my kids favorite place. Their pizza is the best in South Buffalo. The sauce is the perfect amount of sweet and delicious. Always baked to perfection. The staff are always friendly and helpful, and the Company itself is amazing! Their support of the kids in South Buffalo in unparalleled.
PAST DRAWING WINNERS
Courtney, Axe & Arrow
Andy, Backwoods Brewing Co., Portland, OR
Amanda, Home Restaurant, Los Angeles, CA
Jennifer, Mark's City Grill - Columbus, GA
Rebecca, Frank Gourmet - Buffalo, NY
Donna, Dino's Sports Bar - Cape Cod, MA
Karen, This Little Pig - Amherst, NY
Alicia, Plant Based Pizzeria - Atlanta, GA