Skip to main contentWebsite Accessibility Assistance

Buffalo NY Spot for Pizza, Wings & More

Welcome to Wise Guys Pizza. We've called South Buffalo home since 1992, and this neighborhood has called us their favorite ever since. Family-owned and made the right way. From hand-tossed pizza smothered in our famous sweet sauce to crispy wings, hearty subs, hoagies, golden calzones, and full catering spreads that feed a crowd right. Over 30 years in, and we're still putting everything into every order. There's always a seat at our table.

thomas

Follow us @wiseguyspizzsouthbuffalo

Catering 2

Catering Made Easy

Let Wise Guys feed your crowd. From office lunches to backyard parties to family events, we bring South Buffalo's favorites straight to you. Pies with our signature sweet sauce, 30+ wing flavors, subs, hoagies, salads, calzones, and more. Easy ordering, great food, happy people.

Get the Wise Guys Pizza App

Your Wise Guys favorites are just a few taps away. Download the Wise Guys Pizza app to order online, explore the menu, and enjoy an easier way to get your favorite pizza, wings, and more in Buffalo.

Wise Guys App Mockup
Family

OUR STORY

Wise Guys Pizza has called South Buffalo home since 1992. We're not a chain, we're not a franchise, we're a family, and this neighborhood is ours.

Every pie starts with our house-made sweet sauce, a Wise Guys original that's been turning first-timers into regulars for over three decades. Not a sweet sauce person? We've got traditional too but don't knock it till you've tried it. From there, choose from 30+ wing flavors, specialty pizzas, subs, hoagies, calzones, tacos, and more, there's always something worth coming back for.

Beyond the food, we're proud to be woven into the fabric of South Buffalo always supporting local causes, showing up for the community, and doing our part to make this neighborhood a better place. That's what being a local business means to us.

Our Location

Wise Guys Pizza

1965 Seneca St.
Buffalo, NY 14210

(716) 826-8406

    Hours

    Monday - Sunday: 10 am to 9 pm

    Love it? Rate it!

    Leave a Review

    Sheet Cheese

    Absolutely delicious highly recommend excellent pizza and service every single time. I will always order pizza from here

    Melissa

    Stinger Pizza (Steak & Chicken Finger)

    We've ordered here twice in the past week for work functions. Hands down the best pizza I've ever had in Buffalo. Guys working the store were so incredibly kind!!

    Danielle

    Chicken Finger Pizza

    Best Chicken Fingers in Buffalo, their Chicken Finger Pizza is absolute fire!! 10/10 recommend

    Mark J

    Opens in a new windowOpens an external siteOpens an external site in a new window